My New Course: The Knowledge Society and Social Organizations

The Knowledge Society and Social Organizations
SOC4303 A

Karim A.H.A. Hasan
Fall 2012

COURSE OUTLINE

Class schedule: Wednesdays 13:00-14:30
Fridays 11:30-13:00
Room FSS4014

Professor’s office hours: Wednesday 14:30 – 15:30
Office: FSS 10055
Phone 613-562-5800, Ext.1381 (voicemail is not
available)

E-mail:

On virtual campus: No

All questions sent by e-mail should receive a response within two working days or by the next class if it takes place within the 48 hours following receiving the email. Please note that the professor reserves the right to not respond to an email if the level of language is not appropriate.

OFFICIAL COURSE DESCRIPTION

Comprehensive course highlights the articulation between the development of societies, the evolution of science and technologies, and the implementation of a knowledge-based economy. The emphasis is on the central function of higher education in current social transformations as well as the changes resulting from its institutional centrality, especially the creation of academic capitalism.

SPECIFIC COURSE OBJECTIVES

This a fourth year advanced level sociology course which is designed in similar structure as graduate level course. Active learning, participation and contribution of the students are essential to their success in the course. Students must take the responsibility to provide their own readings of the course readings, select the readings of their choice for presentations among the list of readings which have been listed on the course syllabus, the must decide the topic of their choice to write a research essay, which is the final component of course evaluation and does worth 40%.

Those students who successfully complete all the components of the course will obtain knowledge of the discipline of sociology and its readings of the main sociological texts by Comte, Durkheim, Marx, Weber, Habermas, Foucault…etc. about the ways in which Western societies have developed from non-knowledge based, pre-modern social, political and economic structure/organization to modern, knowledge-based societies, which have to be contextualised and applied to present day relevant topics and societal concerns. Interdisciplinary readings of the sociological texts are acceptable if they are accurate, if the readings are relevant to the accepted subfields, sub-disciplines within sociology.

COURSE CONTENT
Bibliography of Required Readings:

Books:

Durkheim, Emile (1984) The Division of Labor in Society, Free Press, New York.

Habermas, Jürgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest, Beacon Press, Boston.

Marx, Karl et., al., (1935) Value, Price and Profit, International Publishers, New York.

Gane, Mike (2006) Auguste Comte, Routldge, New York.

Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organization Studies in the Post-Modern World, Sage, London.

Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, Oxford University Press, New York.

Articles:

Cohen, Stewart (1986) “Knowledge in Context”, The Journal of Philosophy 83, 574-585.

Foucault, Michel (1994) “What is Enlightenment?”, In Paul Rabinow Edition., Essential Works of Foucault 1954 – 1984 – Ethic, Subjectivity and Truth Volume 1, pp. 303-320, Edited by, The New Press, New York.

Foucault, Michel (2000) “Space, Knowledge and Power” In Paul Rabinow Edition., Essential Works of Foucault 1954-1984, Power Volume 3, pp. 349-363, The New Press, New York.

Gettier, Edmund L. (1963) “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?”, Analysis 23, 121-123.

Goldman, Alvin I. (1979) “What is Justified Belief?” In G.S papers, ed., Justification and knowledge: New Studies in Epistemology, Dordrecht: D. Reudel, 1-23.

Kant, Immanuel (1996) “What is Enlightenment?” In What is Enlightenment? Eighteenth Century Answers and Twentieth-Century Questions, James Schmidt Edition, University of California Press, Los Angeles.

Stewart, Crispin (1992) “Why Knowledge is Merely True Belief” The Journal of Philosophy 89, 1967-180.

Schaffer, Jonathan (2005) “Knowing the Answer”, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 75, 383-403.

Weinber, Jonathan M. (2006) “What is Epistemology for? The Case of Neopragmatism in Normative Metaepistemology”, In S. Hetherington, ed., Epistemology Futures, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 26-47.

TEACHING METHODS

Seminar: Active participation is the key to succeed in this course
-Discussions
-Presentations
-Daily attendance
-Research essay

EVALUATION
Attendance 10%
– Attend all the classes and receive full 10% allocated for attendance

Daily Participation, Presentation of a Required Reading 25 %
– Quality and frequency of participation 10%
– Presentation of one reading 15%

Essay Proposal, Presentation of the Proposal 25%
– Written proposal 15%
– Presentation of the proposal 10%

Research Essay 40%

Policy on language quality and late submissions

Class attendance is necessary to successfully complete this course.

You will also be judged on language quality, therefore it is recommended that you take the appropriate measures to avoid mistakes such as spelling, syntax, punctuation, inappropriate use of terms, etc. You may be penalized up to 15%, to the professor’s discretion.

Late submissions are not tolerated. Exceptions are made only for illness or other serious situations deemed as such by the professor. There will be a penalty for unauthorized late submissions. University regulations require all absences from exams and all late submissions due to illness to be supported by a medical certificate.

Absence for any other serious reason must be justified in writing, to the academic assistants of the Faculty, within five business days following the date of the exam or submission of an assignment. The Faculty reserves the right to accept or refuse the reason. Reasons such as travel, jobs, or any misreading of the examination timetable are not acceptable.

In the case of illnesses, only the Counseling Service or a doctor can issue a valid certificate for justification of a late submission or an absence.

A penalty of 5% will be given for each subsequent day following the due date (weekends not included). This goes for assignments submitted through e-mail as well, and, in this case, the time that the e-mail was received will be counted as the time of submission of the document.

We suggest that you advise your professor as early as possible if a religious holiday or a religious event will force you to be absent during an evaluation.

CLASS SCHEDULE

DATE COURSE READINGS ASSIGNMENTS/PRESENTA-TIONS, DUE DATES
Week 1:
Wed., Sept.,5

Friday, Sept. 7

Introduction, administrative matters

Immanuel, Kant (1996) “What is Enlightenment?”…
Foucault, Michel (1994) “What is Enlightenment?”…
Write two paragraphs; reason out why you are taking this course, due on the 7th of Sept

Week 2:
Wed., Sept., 12

Friday, Sept., 14

Book: Gene, Mike (2006) Auguste Comte…
Article: Weinber, Johnathan M. (2006) “What is Epistemology for?”…
Article: Stewart, Crispin (1992) “Why knowledge is Merely True Belief?”…

Week 3:
Wed., Sept., 19

Friday, Sept., 21

Book: Durkheim, Emile (1984) The Division of Labor in Society…
Wed. Sept. 19t
4 Students present the readings of their choice; each student has 22.5 minutes for the presentation, questions and answers. Instructor will moderate

Week 4:
Wed., Sept., 26

Friday, Sept., 28

Article: Foucault, Michel (2000) “Space, Knowledge and Power”… Wed. Sept. 26: Student presentations continue

Week 5:
Wed., Oct., 3

Friday, Oct., 5

___________________________________________________
Book: Marx, Karl, et.,al. (1935) Value, Prince and Profit…

Wed, Oct., 3: Student presentations continue

Week 6:
Wed., Oct., 10

Friday, Oct., 12

Book: Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology…
Wed. Oct. 10: Student presentations continue

_________________________________
Week 7:
Wed., Oct., 17

Friday, Oct., 19
Article: Cohen, Stewart (1986) “Knowledge in Context” …
Article: Gettier, Edmund L. (1963) “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?”…

Friday, Oct. 19: Student presentations continue
Week 8:
Wed., Oct., 24

Friday, Oct., 26

Book: Habermas, Jürgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest…
Wed. Oct. 24: Student presentations continue

Week 9:
Wed., Oct., 31

Friday, Nov., 2
Article: Schaffer, Jonathan (2005) “Knowing the Answer”…
Article: Goldman, Alvin I. (1979) “What is Justified Belief?”…

Friday, Nov. 2: Student presentations Continue
Week 10:
Wed., Nov., 7

Friday, Nov., 9 Book: Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organizations Studies…

Presentation of Essay Proposals

Nov. 9 – Nov 30th presentation of essay proposals
Week 11:
Wed., Nov., 14

Friday, Nov., 16

Week 12:
Wed., Nov., 21

Friday, Nov., 23

Week 13:
Wed., Nov., 28

Friday, Nov., 30

Week 14:
Wed., Dec., 5 (last day of Class)

Friday, Dec., 7
Exam period begins Final Essay is due

Resources for you

Mentoring Centre – http://www.sciencessociales.uottawa.ca/mentor/fra/
The goal of the Mentoring Centre is to help students with their academic and social well being during their time at the University of Ottawa. Regardless of where a student stands academically, or how far along they are in completing their degree, the mentoring centre is there to help students continue on their path to success.

A student may choose to visit the mentoring centre for very different reasons. Younger students may wish to talk to their older peers to gain insight into programs and services offered by the University, while older student may simply want to brush up on study and time management skills or learn about programs and services for students nearing the end of their degree.

In all, the Mentoring Centre offers a place for students to talk about concerns and problems that they might have in any facet of their lives. While students are able to voice their concerns and problems without fear of judgment, mentors can garner further insight in issues unique to students and find a more practical solution to better improve the services that the Faculty of Social Sciences offers, as well as the services offered by the University of Ottawa.

Academic Writing Help Centre – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/writing/
At the AWHC you will learn how to identify, correct and ultimately avoid errors in your writing and become an autonomous writer. In working with our Writing Advisors, you will be able to acquire the abilities, strategies and writing tools that will enable you to:
• Master the written language of your choice
• Expand your critical thinking abilities
• Develop your argumentation skills
• Learn what the expectations are for academic writing

Career Services – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/careers/
Career Services offers various services and a career development program to enable you to recognize and enhance the employability skills you need in today’s world of work.

Counseling Service – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/personal/
There are many reasons to take advantage of the Counseling Service. We offer:
• Personal counseling
• Career counseling
• Study skills counseling

Access Service – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/acces/
The Access Service contributes to the creation of an inclusive environment by developing strategies and implementing measures that aim to reduce the barriers to learning for students who have learning disabilities, health, psychiatric or physical conditions.

Student Resources Centers – http://www.communitylife.uottawa.ca/en/resources.php
The Student Resources Centers aim to fulfill all sorts of students needs.

Be Aware of Academic Fraud!

Academic fraud is an act committed by a student and it can negatively effect your school evaluation (with respect to assignments, tests, exams, etc.). It is not tolerated by the University. Anyone found guilty of fraud will be liable to severe penalties.

Here are some examples of Academic Fraud:
• Plagiarize or cheat in any way;
• Present falsified research data;
• Submission of an assignment that, in part or in entirety, you are not the author of;
• Presentation of, without written permission of the professor(s) concerned, the same work from another course;

Over the years, the perfection of the Internet has strongly facilitated the discovery of cases of plagiarism. The tools that are at the disposal of your professors permit, with the help of only a few words, to retrace the origin of a text on the Web.

For more information on fraud and how to avoid it, you can refer to the Faculty web page, which offers tips to help you with your studies and the writing process for university level projects at the following address: http://www.socialsciences.uottawa.ca/eng/ugrad_tips.asp. You can also refer to the Faculty web page for information on plagiarism and university assignments:
http://www.socialsciences.uottawa.ca/eng/ethics.asp.

The person who committed or attempts to commit academic fraud or who was an accomplice will be punished. Here are some examples of sanctions that could be imposed:
• The assignment or course in question will receive a grade of “F”;
• An additional requirement will be added to the program of study (3 to 30 credits);
• Suspension or expulsion from the Faculty.

Over the past session, the majority of people found guilty of fraud received an “F” in their course and will need to obtain three to twelve extra credits in their program of study.

You may refer to the following address to find the regulations:
http://www.uottawa.ca/academic/info/newsletter/fraud_e.html

____

1
Course Rationale
Course Name: Knowledge Society and Social Organizations
Course Code, Number and Section: SOC 4303 A
Fall 2012
Prof. Karim .A.H.A. Hasan
http://karimhasan.com/about/
Currently, the twenty first century, we live a period which is known in the discipline of sociology “Modern Society”. Modern Society may be characterized and defined as “knowledge society”, which has “complex organizational structure”. It does relay on rationality of knowledge methods in social sciences, human sciences, and natural sciences, knowledge methods of “cost-benefit” analysis, “laissez-fair” theories and methods in economic management. The decline in the elementary forms of management and governance of life certainly has been noted with the emergence and formalization of scientific knowledge methods of the enlightenment period, the industrial revolution, and capitalist system of production.

Knowledge is accurate result of operationalization of tested outcome of variables, concepts, which may require a number of methods and tests of rational/logical validity and justifications generally defined: epistemic validation. Epistemic validations do rely on methods of evidence, facts. Validations require, formulated programmatic project provisions, for example, solution of problems, curing an illness, building a school, writing a legislation, formulating a new constitution to free a nation/to lead a nation to total freedom from bondage…etc. are processes and projects of knowledge constructions.

We have two major categories of knowledge which are produced and constructed with different methods of knowledge production. The first category is scholarly, academic, formal knowledge which requires specific methods, formal organizations, educational institutions, and the government all together form the “formal knowledge system”. The second is non-formal knowledge, which is categorized “practical knowledge”. Practical knowledge is obtained through trial and error method of

knowledge production. Formal methods and processes of knowledge production are rigorous, rule-based, may need laboratory testing, scholastic methods for researching the subject-matter, they are less likely to go wrong, more accurate, in particular the natural sciences, medicine, engineering…etc. Similarly, in the discipline of sociology and other social sciences formal processes of knowledge production follow the similar process and procedure of rationalization, hypothesis formulations and testing.

The non-formal knowledge is produced in the realm of everyday-life experiences and practices. It draws justification and validation methods “practical reason”, which mobilized trial-error method to produce a category of knowledge that we define “practical knowledge”, because it gets obtained in practice without real, actual prior intended formulation and agenda in certain instances. Thus, practical knowledge production requires less formal methods, they emerge out of trial-error method application of common sense practices of problem solving projects.

Although our society and its individual members, modern society in the twenty first century in the formal and non-formal spheres of life do rely on “knowledge” of the living and non-living to organize itself, to rationalize its structure, to make choices , to decide and categorize its goals, to decide and define “good”, “bad”…etc. This main characteristic of modern society that it is a “knowledge society”, in the twenty first century, religion and culture are two main fields of belief and practice which operate in the realm of “practical knowledge, practical reason”.

At best, the knowledge and rationality embedded in the two systems of knowledge production are not based on belief, of which trial-error and common sense methods are not actually accepted as knowledge production procedures until such point in time that the result is clearly received. The likelihoods of failure in trial-error methods and common sense methods are eight out of ten higher than the tested proved method formal methods of knowledge production. “Culture and belief” do not operate on principles of scientific knowledge. The rationality, which is a decisive measure of validity about whether a practice, an activity is accepted on the basis of principles of valid, verifiable scientific knowledge are not a preference influenced by prejudices, cultural up-brining, beliefs, religion, and the conditionings associated with them.

The formal sphere of government and economic activities do mainly rely on cost-benefit analysis, calculative-thinking, which are practices grounded in scientific formulations in economic methods of probabilities for deciding economic vales, prices, profits and wages in the management and

governance of the health, wealth and safety of the society. The formal sphere of government with the associated economic activities do require high level of professionalism, bureaucracy and administrative management, which are dependent on the rational episteme of management and governance of modern societies and their formal – complex associated organizations.

The laws which govern modern societies, societies like ours, are enforced by the government, its ministries, the quasi-government organizations to which the government has delegated power to act on behalf of the government, the civil society organizations which are governed by those laws explicitly and implicitly rely on justification and validations that decision-making method processes and universal principles, which extend justice to everyone regardless of age, sex, age, colour, race, national origin…etc, are based on scientific knowledge.

Constitutional legal guarantees of universal justice are guarantees of equal rights, equal opportunities…etc, for all of citizens; they are the product of scientific research and the accumulation of knowledge of practices of justice, which evades non-rational, invalid, prejudicial discrimination. Any errors and misjudgments in law are reviewable and appealable; the legislations which do not pass the test of constitutionality are sent back to parliament for amendments and corrections.

Thus, the laws which govern our society are rational, knowledge-based, our laws are not arbitrary. Practices of democracy, “peace, order and good governance” and “responsible government” are categories of practices which have been formulated and institutionalized as the result of precise and accurate knowledge of governance over centuries of accumulation of knowledge in management and government.
Modern society, which emerged at the end of seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries scientific revolution, discoveries and innovations in technology, engineering have led to innovations in communication technology, i.e., the telephone, internet, satellite communication technology, space exploration, embryo research, genetic modification of plants, vegetables, fruits and of humans specie.

Continuous and progressive research in social, political and economic sciences have produced new knowledge about governance and management of the society, that criticised the status-quo during the enlightenment period, which continues to this date, an age of criticism, rethinking, review, re-evaluation of social, political, economic and religious life. The beginning of individuality, rights and freedoms of individual responsibilities are characteristics of modern societies. The “indivisible sovereign authority”, the model upon which the

kings, queens, emperors and other earthly sovereign powers drew inspiration to establish “Omniscient and Omnipotent and Omnipresent” authority of their subjects, similar to the authority of “God” on the earth were divided at the dawn of modernity among the religious institutions, the nobility, the kings courts…etc, thereafter among institutions of government, civil society…etc.

French revolution in later part of eighteenth century brought the most important change and innovation to nature of power and governance. It took to pieces the unanimity of absolute sovereignty, the revolution shattered absolute sovereignty, divided it and returned the power to people, institutionalized a new form of sovereignty, which is a celebrated respectable practice of democracy, the revolution made “people the sovereign”, known in political science “popular sovereignty”. The French revolution showed a progressive-knowledge-based change to the rest of Europe, which had not been seen in Europe in centuries. The revolution did vanquish the symbols of indivisible absolute sovereignty and freed the people from the shackles of ignorance; it was a progressive-change which almost entire Europe did follow.

What was, were the reasons which made those changes and the emergence of institutionalization of knowledge-based society possible? What was, were the causes which necessitated those new developments which led to the emergence of knowledge based society and its associated organizations, and how did it happen?

The successful institutionalization and formalization of the new rational system which provided the base-knowledge for formation of knowledge society, modern society, were mainly due to the fallacies, inefficiencies of the pre-modern system of governance and management which relied on arbitrary, non-rational system of governance of the health, wealth, freedoms of the society. Thus, health, wealth, justice, freedom, safety …etc, of the society in general necessitated new techniques and methods of knowledge production, a number of these new techniques and methods were discovered through programmatic projects, rational-calculative projects, the other category were discovered by accident and through ordinary trial-error activities of everyday life.

The opponents of reason, justice, modernity and knowledge-based society have been challenging the management and governance of the society, they are distorting the principles and applications of scientific knowledge, which are valid and justifiable universally, they are timeless and everlasting necessary for our safety, security, health, wealth…etc. We, the defenders/protectors of knowledge, justice, freedom, reason may continue to find ourselves in this unreasonable, unjustifiable

war with the “other side”, with opponents of enlightenment project who reject science, justice, freedom based on their own cultural prejudices and their “belief”, because the “other side” does not come to terms and does not consent to the principles of accurate knowledge justifiable by scientific methods which support freedom, justice, rights equally regardless of race, gender, ethnicity, religion…etc.
Henceforth, any form of consensus may only be mediated /negotiated by “law” or “alliance of temporary interests”. Thus, we must not expect an end to the quarrel between knowledge and belief. People may find themselves, either take a clear side, be moderate observant critically …etc. or they may find themselves unable to a take clear position which is difficult to hold and to maintain. Despite all those tensions, knowledge and its associated practices of justice, freedom are living being which constantly have progressed for thousands of years and will continue in similar direction as have been in the past to the present.

Synopsis of the Main Readings
This synopsis has been organized chronologically starting with earliest sociologists and social scientists.

Mike, Gane (2006) Auguste Comte, Routledge, New York.
Reading Auguste Comte (1798-1857) who is one of the main early founders of sociology is central to the understanding of discipline of sociology. A good, through education in society must begin with the reading of Auguste Comte. Comte is recognized as the founder of “positive sociology – positive polity”, which is “secular humanism”, “religion of humanism”, concepts and practices that have contributed to the sub-discipline of “sociology of science” and recognition of sociology as “social science”.
Comte is a forgotten sociologist. His works range in dozens of very, very important large volumes of books, which have provide the discipline of sociology certain findings and teachings that have been central for the understanding the development of human societies with newly innovative research methods he questioned the traditional non-scientific, cultural prejudicial belief fallacies that governed formal and non-formal system of thoughts and practices. Although Comte’s own personal life does not reflect his works, we do really have to read his works in the context of his time period, the context of the social, political and economic conditions which governed France during his time period.

Humanism, positivism, scientific methods of inquiry in social sciences are approach and methods, which Comte contributed to the discipline of sociology and social sciences are very relevant to present-day discipline of sociology subject matters in university teaching and in real life sphere. They are the sources we have to rely on to read and to limit diversions from knowledge to arbitrary non-scientific methods of governance and management of the society. Comte’s works, scientific methods of inquiry, his contribution to the study of law are excellent start to begin advanced studies and understanding of the discipline of sociology and social sciences.

Marx, Karl, et. al., (1935) Value, Price, and Profit, International Publishers, New York.
Although Karl Marx (1818-1883) has been, is, considered one of the major sociologists – political economists in academic – scholarly communities, his ideological belief and associations with “political socialism” and “political communism”, and his call on the working class to destroy capitalist system of production, have led to categorization of his work as non-objective, ideological and politically oriented. As the result, scholars of who consider their own work within the category of objectivity, who claim that knowledge must be scientific-objective, value laden, non-ideological have been weary and skeptical of admitting Karl Marx’s work openly in academic – scholarly communities of associations.

His criticisms and evaluations of capitalist method – system of production that capitalist system of production ends, and that the system falls within itself because of certain internal deficiencies and quarrel within it, thereafter leads to new form of social, political and economic life “socialism” and then “communism”, which according to Marx will occur in the form of “working class revolution” to over turn capitalist system of production has been proven inaccurate. Current, discreet and more accurate analysis and studies reveal that Marx’s certain studies capital system of production and his critique of political economy are highly scientific, which have contributed to knowledge of economic production, but his political ideology is inaccurate and highly unlikely to receive further consideration.

However, his work which focuses on “production, value, price, profit and wage” presents basic – fundamental evaluation of capitalist system of production are highly accurate, and his criticisms are supplementary to the understandings of certain fallacies, injustices inherent within capitalist system of production, henceforth, reading and understanding Karl Marx’s work, the sociologist – political economist, not Karl Marx the “socialist – communist” is every important and necessary for all students of sociology and the sub-field of political economy with the discipline of sociology.

Fair, justifiable, viable balance of values, price, profit, wages are central to the foundation and functioning system of economic production. Thus, understanding criticisms which Marx presented may lead to further review of capitalist system of production and class based society, in which the classes live at certain degree of conflict over the means and ends of economic production. Marx’s contribution to sociology is the organization of the society into classes in accordance with their economic power and ownership of the means of production is accurate reading of political economy.

Durkheim, Emile (1984) The division of Labor in Society, Free Press, New York.
Distinguishing and organizing the differences and similarities in the division of labor force are governed differently in pre-modern and modern societies. In pre-modern societies the form of organization – solidarity is “mechanical”, which is a simple form of social organization and division of labor.

According to Durkheim (1858-1917), “organic solidarity” is the form of social organization and division of labor in modern societies, in which mode or economic production is capitalist. Durkheim’s Division of Labor is one of the most important sociological sources, which shows the ways in which progress / development from primitive – elementary forms of mechanical solidarity of social organization that consists of arbitrary, non-knowledge based, non-scientific methods of governance of social, political and economic life did no-longer hold the capacity, and lost the validity as the system of organization and management.

Mechanical form of solidarity organizes communities into simple communal life, their leaders do posses and they are accepted as charismatic leaders who are followed as sacred, spiritual guides, “gurus” who serve their communities without any reward. They are accepted as if they were appointed to the task by the high supreme-being. Communal life in mechanical solidarity is similar to “cyborg” communities which we see in science fiction movies, life is commanded / managed at the centre; the community follows the same order without questionings and doubts. In “mechanical solidarity” system sovereigns and charismatic leaders possess privacy; the nobility, religious institutions, the sovereign’s associates enjoy privacy when the sovereign, the charismatic leader delegate – grant a degree of private life.
Consequently, cause and effect has led to formation of a new form of social organization proper for modern societies, which is a knowledge-based society. “Organic solidarity” is system of organization

which relies on science, knowledge, evidence, justification, validation and the rationale of complex system of associations and consociation of organizations in which individuals and groups are members, who are working for the same or similar objectives. Individualism does find a welcoming space and place within mechanical form of social solidarity. The sources of authority in modern society, which is organized in the form of “organic solidarity”, although relevant to modern norms, are important; the “Law” is a formal system, rules and regulations which supplement the law apply to the public, and to private spheres of life at certain instances.

The division between public and private receives far more technical interpretation. Private domain-sphere which was only the luxury and domain of the kings, queens and the sovereigns, extended to ordinary citizens alike. In organic solidarity in modern societies, system of rights, responsibilities and freedoms do allow group interest formations which are legally / formally recognized. They may not be in agreement with their concurrent government and authority; however, “unity in diversity” may be the best term to describe the constituent collision of interests, remains within the framework of broader system and a wider communal good than the presumed communal good which mainly the sovereign, the charismatic leader and their associates defined, enjoyed and were the beneficiaries.
Almost a century and half has passed since the passing of Emile Durkheim, the French sociologist, his work remains highly relevant to our present day – modern society, his work remains central to the discipline of sociology and social sciences.

Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essay in Sociology, Oxford University Press, New York.
Max Weber (1958-1917) German sociologist, have contributed to sociology is mainly in the fields of “economy and society”. His life begun at the dawn of modern –industrial revolution in Europe, a period in which complex social, political and economic activities were necessitating new formation of social, political and economic organization for the management and the governance of the society. Cause and effect explanation would be a highly accurate approach by which change from elementary form of organization to modern knowledge-based from of organization may be explained – as Weber has presented in his work.

Weber’s concerns and focus of studies among others: bureaucracy and charisma, forms of administration, science and politics, power, class, status, party-politics, social structures, religion in the East and West. Unlike the scholars and scientists who argued and defended that the “enlightenment project” was the initial intellectual programmatic beginning of change toward modernity, rationality, justice, individual freedom, freedom from traditional authority of religion, in particular the Church and Papacy, over ordinary life in the “earthly city”. Weber related the rise of the modern freedom from “religion” and the formation of modern rational society to “Puritan Anglo-American Tradition”i which he finds in the “spiritual revolution: the Protestant Reformation of the Sixteenth Century”ii.

Although Weber’s claim and research that “protestant reformation” with “Puritan Anglo-American Tradition” have lead the development of Western societies to modern social, political and economic system-structure to which capital mode of production is the economic-base, has a degree of accuracy, Weber’s reliance on the reformation movement as the central departing point from the traditions of the middle ages and previous system of government, which he has claimed to have been the leading intellectual movement that founded and formed modern societies is inaccurate and simplistic.

More accurate explanation is that an aggregate of social, political, economic movements, new scientific discoveries, industrial revolution, French Revolution rose at the centre of Catholicism, descendents of Charlemagne of France brought new form of governance, ended absolutism, replaced it with republican-democratic rule, rule of the people, for the people, by the people, a type revolution which spread all over Europe in the decades and centuries thereafter; Renaissance – rebirth of cultural practices in South East Europe in particular Italian Renaissance, which are selected collection of practices in social, political intellectual movements from perhaps early Greek philosophers and aristocracy, the “philosophers kings”…etc., and their Middle Eastern roots are all aggregates of knowledge practices which have contributed to the formation of modern rational, knowledge-based societies.

French Revolution is element of the Enlightenment project, which has inspired and aided the United States of America’s formation to freedom. Thus, although Weber remains an important classical sociologist, whose work is yet relevant, he shows us many details of the development of Western societies to modern, knowledge based societies, his account, claiming all the credit to the protestant reformation is inaccurate.

Weber’s relevancy to this course may be summarized in three main points. First, Weber is one of the founder/elaborators of discipline of formal sociology of modern societies, knowledge-based society. Second, Weber is one of the first sociologists who wrote on modern social, political and economic organizations; he provided extensive analysis most components of modern societies, which he successfully showed that they are not based on arbitrary methods of governance, rather they function on principles re rationality, bureaucratic administration…etc.

Third, Weber’s ‘sociology of religion’ provides an excellent comparative analysis of the principle claims religions of West, Middle Easter and Eastern religions, the centrality of reason and rationality, their application to worldly life, pragmatism, are the main analytic and evaluation criterion. Weber uses rationality and knowledge in similar way, if the two were the identical. Although “knowledge” and “reason” are interrelated and connected, they are not the equivalent.
Habermas, Jϋrgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest, Beacon Press, Boston.

Knowledge and Human Interest shows the ways in which human interest influences production of knowledge and justification for selection of certain choice-makings, which are driven-caused by human interest, certain interests are justified and allowed, certain specified interested are regulated or prohibited. The nature of knowledge is such that it is influenced by interest, where there is space for manipulation of knowledge which operates the system; there are limited acceptable choices within the system among the available choices.

The selection method of choice making must be justified on principles of justice and reason, which to contribute to the formation of the system that has been built – structured on the type of knowledge equipped with universal justice and reason. Habermas is the defender of Enlightenment project, the centrality of reason, universal justice…etc. The epistemological validation which attempts to free knowledge from interest does fail, if interest is not regulated and governed by the universal principle of knowledge, mainly because interest is the motive and the drive, which may divert knowledge formation to unjustified, invalid directions that may lead to epistemic-failure. Although, “human interest” is the central driving force, the motif which pushes forward the process of knowledge formation of material objects, construction of formal social, political and

economic system and practical knowledge of everyday life; interest cannot be an inherently acceptable cause of knowledge that leads to justified, valid, free-good life, which is governed by just-law.
Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organization Studies in the Post-Modern World, Sage, London.
Although it is not the purpose of this course to focus on modernity and post-modernity debates, debates which intent to define, to characterize whether we live in the modern or the postmodern period, because this course’s main focus is the study of knowledge society and its relevant models/methods of organization and the development from pre-modern to modern knowledge-based system, it is useful to include a source which brings the development of “organizations” to attention.

If clearly we agree either that we live in postmodern social, political and economic system, or if we agree about its recent emergence, or if we agree that modern social, political and economic system has not passed and still we live in the modern period, in either instance of these “if-clauses”, the answer to the main question which this course focuses on would have a different impact for “the universality of knowledge”, “standardization of knowledge”, whether we live in knowledge-based society, will cause further differentiations, distinctions, and different consequences for the management and governance of the social, political and economic system.

Postmodern approach to “knowledge and organization” is different than modern approach to “knowledge and organization”. Standard and measurements which knowledge is assessed and defined in postmodern society may differ from the modern definitions and standards of knowledge.

References
Durkheim, Emile (1984) The division of Labor in Society, Free Press, New York.
Habermas, Jurgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest, Beacon Press, Boston.
Mike, Gane (2006) Auguste Comte, Routledge, New York.
Max, Karl, et. al., (1935) Value, Price, and Profit, International Publishers, New York.
Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organization Studies in the Post-Modern World, Sage, London.
Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essay in Sociology, Oxford University Press, New York.
Weber, Max (2002) The Protestant Ethics and the “Spirit” of Capitalism and other Writings, Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, England.
i Weber, Max () Protestant Ethics and Spirit of Capitalism… P., x
ii Ibid, at P., ix

The Kurdish President and the Kurdish President

President Jalal Talabani, the pro-modernity, progressive social democrat, leader of Kurdish movement for independence, now the president of the Federal Republic of Iraq 2005-2012, after the formation of new chaotic almost ‘failed state’ of Iraq has been considered by the coalition forces, the different political groups the wise man who would lead Iraq in new age of federal, multi-party, parliamentary democracy; and Kurds certainly entrusted him that he would protect Kurdish rights and freedoms in accordance with Kurdish constitutional rights if necessary an independent Kurdish state.

He accepted a daunting, difficult statesmanship position in the new state of Iraq, which entails two contradictory goals, two conflicting objective luminal and seminal of two historical projects.

His certain accomplishments are expressed and visible in his willingness and courage to take up this difficult task, which never has been a statesmanship position in the state of Iraq, responsibility to represent Iraq versus responsibility to represent Kurdistan. These contradictory responsibilities have certainly contributed to the deterioration of his health and success in his duties – Iraqi president and secretary general of PUK.

Not for this specific leader but for any leader who take such duty, in that certain party of the world with that certain political culture, with that specific certain social, political and economic structure and religious-mania enshrined in the formal and informal spheres of life, failure is certain in representing an invaded nation, Kurds, and an invading nation, Iraq.

It is not the leader, person, in question, it is the position, the tasks and the duties, which are appointed to the position do hinder the leader’s ability to accomplish, to succeed. Simply, the post of Iraqi presidency has made the Kurdish president vulnerable.

His political party, PUK, which was first and more powerful among the Kurdish political parties in Kurdistan, now has been is shattered and divided in two: Gorran, change movement, which is led by Nawshirwan Mustafa and Gorran council, president Talabani former deputy and second in command in PUK.

He can still make a wiser decision and safe himself; rescue himself Iraq’s chaotic politics, the many contradictory tasks which have been wasting his time, energy and historical harm to the development of Kurdish rights and freedoms, to which historical responsibility and liability are assigned. Withdrawal from Iraqi alliance and unification with Gorran will save PUK and their close allies and would lead to realization of Kurdish independence.

I am genuinely saddened by the recent news about the deterioration of his health, which has been reported on 18, 19, Dec. 2012. I pray for his safety and wellbeing.

President Masoud Barzani, leader of undemocratic Kurdistan Democratic Party, obtained his authority from tribal and familial influence; his authority and power are derived from tribe, family, economic wealth, leader of Kurdistan Democratic Party since 1979, president of Kurdistan Region since 2005.

His wisdom was once forecasted within certain smaller political groups and Kurdish individuals that he would is, and he would become the protector Kurdish rights and freedoms, he would represent Kurdistan and Kurdish without discrimination of region, locality, dialect, political belief.

Contrary to the task to which he has assigned himself to, and accepted he adamantly and stubbornly has been plotting to increase his own, his family’s and his political party’s influence. Almost 16 members of his own family have positioned themselves at the top, highest ranks of KDP, KRG and Iraq; they have invaded the KDP and turned it into an undemocratic political party.

Using money, and certain techniques, his political party has been making gains in areas which have been PUK regions, in early stages KDP was mainly responsible for inflecting divisive ideas within the ranks of PUK, however, Gorran has clearly declared that its platform is different from KDP, thus alliance with KDP would not be an option until such time that KDP and Kurdish alliance follow Gorran’s recommendations.

In summer 2009 KDP sphere of influence increased, Barzani was re-elected the president of KRG, many instances of fraud, bribery, abnormality in voting specifically in KDP regions. KDP has been making gains and extending its spheres of influence until the emergence of Gorran and in particular 2010-2011 movements in Sulaimani and Hawler region, which stopped the expansion of KDP’s singular political agenda.

President Masoud Barzani’s duties and task are simple, singular-representation of Kurds and Kurdistan, a statesmanship position which has been exploited for gains of his political parties and familial influence. In the last 7 years he and his office has not been able to establish the facts of the legal rights and freedoms of the Kurdish people neither in Baghdad neither regionally nor internationally.

His work method and hidden agenda for specific gains, which are not prescribed in KRG constitution, and Kurdish political project for independence would hold him responsible historically for failing to lead, for failing to be the president of Kurdistan. I pray that he will find common good and justice.

* Regardless of those inadequacies, lack of influential wise leadership Kurdistan society to lead the Kurds to independence, modernity …etc. Kurdistan is making progress, a kind of progress which is the right path to democracy, justice, independence, they are better than their neighbors. They are not invading; they are not exploiting…etc. their neighbors.

The Horrific shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary

by Karim Hasan on Wednesday, December 19, 2012 at 3:29pm ·

I was shocked in disbelieve and dismay, when I heard the news of the horrific shooting at Sandy Hook, Connecticut elementary school, which killed 20 children and 6 adults, on Friday, December 14, 2012; a mass murder and massacre of school children and their teachers…etc. Yet again, the unthinkable happened, only a few months ago in another state a shooting took place in a movie theatre, which was also a mass murder criminal act.

To whom we should send our condolences, whom should we comfort…etc.? Certainly, the innocents and the victims, and pray that their souls be saved and rest in peace in cases like this the nation should be comforted and held in close support…etc. Stand with the victims and the innocents; vow that the villains and criminals will be brought to justice. This is the task and duty of all who deem themselves to take responsibility of the safety, security of our children, the communities in which they live…etc.

However, an important point which we have to remind ourselves is the fact that we have allowed the means by which certain acts of violence and crime may occur. The right to own and carry a gun/firearm is a right that has been interpreted in general as an absolute right of all citizens, which we have to restrict, limit, regulate to own, to carry in certain situations, zones…etc.

Failure to protect and to provide safe orderly life is the failure of the authority who have sworn to protect and the public, the citizenry who are careless about enactment and their choices of laws, ownership… etc. In so many instances and cases of failure and misuse of the right to own and carry gun/firearm, which have ended in killing thousands of innocent citizens in the United States…etc. to whom we should send our condolences and for whom should open our arms of comfort? To all of us, for all of us, because while we are victims are also the failed citizens, authorities either have become accomplice or criminal for allowing the laws, which allow errors and possible mischief…etc. Our civilization has failed to eliminate mental illness, maniacs, criminals, we certainly can end gun ownership, carry…etc. in private capacity…etc.

Then we should all sit, convene, meet, grief, weep together for victimizing ourselves, and for our lack of ability to find, agree, apply an accurate, precise method, a just solution which may end killings of innocent people, young, old, professionals, students, male, female…etc. by thousands every year.

May god bless the souls of those innocent children, the teachers and staff who were killed in Sandy Hook elementary school, in Connecticut and comfort their families. I am certain a solution will be found…etc.

Note: Republican Candidate Governor Romney is the winner of the 3 presidential debates

Republican Candidate Governor Romney is the winner of the 3 presidential debates.

In the presidential debates republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney has performed better and showed evidence that he will be the commander in chief who will successfully lead the United States of America domestically and internationally…etc.

1)
After the first debate which mainly focused on domestic issues relevant to president’s duties and responsibilities, his projects and plans for running the country, republican candidate did received high approval rate, high 70s and low 63% depending on the polls, purpose and population who were asked the question, who performed better and who would be likely future president of the United States…etc.

2) The second debate was town hall style questions and answers, questions from the moderator and the audience, candidates did respond, explained, argued and followed. The debate covered domestic and foreign policy. To be specific, a few of the questions from the audience and the moderator did not properly receive attention or intentionally diverted to semi-relevant response. While the other questions, which were nearly received proper attention, were explained in relatively similar light, republican candidate Romney preformed better on foreign policy, job creation-employment and women’s right to choose, abortion, contraception / women’s equality in the work place…etc.

A) Republican candidate was given less time to speak, precisely according to my records 3.46 minutes less than president Obama, based on the CNN time, appeared on the bottom right hand side of the TV screen.

President Obama = 44.04 minutes; republican candidate = 40.50. B) Romney’s criticisms of president Obama’s foreign policy were valid and precise, although less elaborate than necessary…etc.

C) Job creation, republican candidate Romney did respond to the questions and explained in detail his job creation project, dollars, numbers, facts and figured were given…etc.

E) Women’s right to choose in matters of abortion, contraception; equality in the work place, equal pay for equal work: The traditional / classical approach which mainly focuses on rights and individualism does not provide sufficient necessary attention to the health, wealth, safety the society and in particular women. Individual women rights to abortion, contraception do burden women with the alone responsibility, because their decision may not always be welcomed/accepted by their family, related and their social network, henceforth contrary decision may bring further burdens…etc.

(i) Women’s right and freedom to choose:

Approach endorsed by democrats, traditionally, women’s right to choose did receive consideration for formalization for two main reasons. First, the universalization guaranteed rights and freedoms their extension to women, the suffrage movement…etc. Second, along with accepting to take their rights and freedoms to choose, the responsibility to choose was loaded on women as the consequence of being master of their own destiny. The democrats do guarantee the first and the second rights and freedoms to choose, plus possible limited support for their choice-making if support is necessary…etc.

mocrats’ approach has a number of problems. First, it loads the responsibility and the burden on women, and the consequences may be (1) socially out-casted, reduction of social safety-net; leaving their family network which could be expensive and in need of a higher paying job; having less time to look after caring for themselves. (2) Cost of public spending / expenditure may rise. (3) While we generally assume that adult over 21 are capable for making the right choice, in application capable decision makers do face with the responsibility and burdens which are have not been calculated and intended to happen; mainly because the guaranteed constitutional right “life, liberty and security of the person [including women]…etc.” may not be separated from the person’s health, wealth, safety, and public health, wealth and safety…etc.

Costs of choosing for pleasure without due diligence may be high enough to outweigh the pleasure of choice making as matter of individual right and freedom, if the choice making is uncalculated, unintended, unsupervised, irrational. While the republican approach does not abandon the application of constitutional principle, it intends to reduce women’s burden in making the right choice, not an absolute right to choice but the right to rational, healthy, caring communal choice, which takes into account the principle of “sanctity of life” and shares the burden of right choice making with women…etc. In constrcuting conceptual defination and practical application of choice – the fathers’ rights and freedoms must be taking into account and respect, thus allocation of obsolute of right given to women must not universally accepted…etc.

(ii) Equal pay for equal work, equality in the work place:

From republican candidate Romney and president Obama’s response, the gathered the following response – conclusion: While democrats design more program to ensure equal pay for equal work and equality in the work place; republicans simply treat and deal with men and women equally without discrimination…etc.

Governor Romney response was more in line with equality and less expensive approach to equality…etc.

* Most importantly, it must be acknowleged that vetrans under current administratn receive less care and attention than necessary, as governor Romney pointed out…etc. (added)

** Romney 63%. After first debate Romney received 63% approval, this approval rate seems to be standing. Do not let “reverse discrimination” take place in American presidential election. “Merit” is quintessential criterion of success…etc.

My New Course: The Knowledge Society and Social Organizations

Hopefully will be taught next term:

The Knowledge Society and Social Organizations
SOC4303 A

Karim A.H.A. Hasan
Fall 2012

COURSE OUTLINE

Class schedule: Wednesdays 13:00-14:30
Fridays 11:30-13:00
Room FSS4014

Professor’s office hours: Wednesday 14:30 – 15:30

E-mail:

On virtual campus: No

All questions sent by e-mail should receive a response within two working days or by the next class if it takes place within the 48 hours following receiving the email. Please note that the professor reserves the right to not respond to an email if the level of language is not appropriate.

OFFICIAL COURSE DESCRIPTION

Comprehensive course highlights the articulation between the development of societies, the evolution of science and technologies, and the implementation of a knowledge-based economy. The emphasis is on the central function of higher education in current social transformations as well as the changes resulting from its institutional centrality, especially the creation of academic capitalism.

SPECIFIC COURSE OBJECTIVES

This a fourth year advanced level sociology course which is designed in similar structure as graduate level course. Active learning, participation and contribution of the students are essential to their success in the course. Students must take the responsibility to provide their own readings of the course readings, select the readings of their choice for presentations among the list of readings which have been listed on the course syllabus, the must decide the topic of their choice to write a research essay, which is the final component of course evaluation and does worth 40%.

Those students who successfully complete all the components of the course will obtain knowledge of the discipline of sociology and its readings of the main sociological texts by Comte, Durkheim, Marx, Weber, Habermas, Foucault…etc. about the ways in which Western societies have developed from non-knowledge based, pre-modern social, political and economic structure/organization to modern, knowledge-based societies, which have to be contextualised and applied to present day relevant topics and societal concerns. Interdisciplinary readings of the sociological texts are acceptable if they are accurate, if the readings are relevant to the accepted subfields, sub-disciplines within sociology.

COURSE CONTENT
Bibliography of Required Readings:

Books:

Durkheim, Emile (1984) The Division of Labor in Society, Free Press, New York.

Habermas, Jürgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest, Beacon Press, Boston.

Marx, Karl et., al., (1935) Value, Price and Profit, International Publishers, New York.

Gane, Mike (2006) Auguste Comte, Routldge, New York.

Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organization Studies in the Post-Modern World, Sage, London.

Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, Oxford University Press, New York.

Articles:

Cohen, Stewart (1986) “Knowledge in Context”, The Journal of Philosophy 83, 574-585.

Foucault, Michel (1994) “What is Enlightenment?”, In Paul Rabinow Edition., Essential Works of Foucault 1954 – 1984 – Ethic, Subjectivity and Truth Volume 1, pp. 303-320, Edited by, The New Press, New York.

Foucault, Michel (2000) “Space, Knowledge and Power” In Paul Rabinow Edition., Essential Works of Foucault 1954-1984, Power Volume 3, pp. 349-363, The New Press, New York.

Gettier, Edmund L. (1963) “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?”, Analysis 23, 121-123.

Goldman, Alvin I. (1979) “What is Justified Belief?” In G.S papers, ed., Justification and knowledge: New Studies in Epistemology, Dordrecht: D. Reudel, 1-23.

Kant, Immanuel (1996) “What is Enlightenment?” In What is Enlightenment? Eighteenth Century Answers and Twentieth-Century Questions, James Schmidt Edition, University of California Press, Los Angeles.

Stewart, Crispin (1992) “Why Knowledge is Merely True Belief” The Journal of Philosophy 89, 1967-180.

Schaffer, Jonathan (2005) “Knowing the Answer”, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 75, 383-403.

Weinber, Johnathan M. (2006) “What is Epistemology for? The Case of Neopragmatism in Normative Metaepistemology”, In S. Hetherington, ed., Epistemology Futures, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 26-47.

TEACHING METHODS

Seminar: Active participation is the key to succeed in this course
-Discussions
-Presentations
-Daily attendance
-Research essay

EVALUATION
Attendance 10%
– Attend all the classes and receive full 10% allocated for attendance

Daily Participation, Presentation of a Required Reading 25 %
– Quality and frequency of participation 10%
– Presentation of one reading 15%

Essay Proposal, Presentation of the Proposal 25%
– Written proposal 15%
– Presentation of the proposal 10%

Research Essay 40%

Policy on language quality and late submissions

Class attendance is necessary to successfully complete this course.

You will also be judged on language quality, therefore it is recommended that you take the appropriate measures to avoid mistakes such as spelling, syntax, punctuation, inappropriate use of terms, etc. You may be penalized up to 15%, to the professor’s discretion.

Late submissions are not tolerated. Exceptions are made only for illness or other serious situations deemed as such by the professor. There will be a penalty for unauthorized late submissions. University regulations require all absences from exams and all late submissions due to illness to be supported by a medical certificate.

Absence for any other serious reason must be justified in writing, to the academic assistants of the Faculty, within five business days following the date of the exam or submission of an assignment. The Faculty reserves the right to accept or refuse the reason. Reasons such as travel, jobs, or any misreading of the examination timetable are not acceptable.

In the case of illnesses, only the Counseling Service or a doctor can issue a valid certificate for justification of a late submission or an absence.

A penalty of 5% will be given for each subsequent day following the due date (weekends not included). This goes for assignments submitted through e-mail as well, and, in this case, the time that the e-mail was received will be counted as the time of submission of the document.

We suggest that you advise your professor as early as possible if a religious holiday or a religious event will force you to be absent during an evaluation.

CLASS SCHEDULE

DATE COURSE READINGS ASSIGNMENTS/PRESENTA-TIONS, DUE DATES
Week 1:
Wed., Sept.,5

Friday, Sept. 7

Introduction, administrative matters

Immanuel, Kant (1996) “What is Enlightenment?”…
Foucault, Michel (1994) “What is Enlightenment?”…
Write two paragraphs; reason out why you are taking this course, due on the 7th of Sept

Week 2:
Wed., Sept., 12

Friday, Sept., 14

Book: Gene, Mike (2006) Auguste Comte…
Article: Weinber, Jonathan M. (2006) “What is Epistemology for?”…
Article: Stewart, Crispin (1992) “Why knowledge is Merely True Belief?”…

Week 3:
Wed., Sept., 19

Friday, Sept., 21

Book: Durkheim, Emile (1984) The Division of Labor in Society…
Wed. Sept. 19t
4 Students present the readings of their choice; each student has 22.5 minutes for the presentation, questions and answers. Instructor will moderate

Week 4:
Wed., Sept., 26

Friday, Sept., 28

Article: Foucault, Michel (2000) “Space, Knowledge and Power”… Wed. Sept. 26: Student presentations continue

Week 5:
Wed., Oct., 3

Friday, Oct., 5

___________________________________________________
Book: Marx, Karl, et.,al. (1935) Value, Prince and Profit…

Wed, Oct., 3: Student presentations continue

Week 6:
Wed., Oct., 10

Friday, Oct., 12

Book: Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology…
Wed. Oct. 10: Student presentations continue

_________________________________
Week 7:
Wed., Oct., 17

Friday, Oct., 19
Article: Cohen, Stewart (1986) “Knowledge in Context” …
Article: Gettier, Edmund L. (1963) “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?”…

Friday, Oct. 19: Student presentations continue
Week 8:
Wed., Oct., 24

Friday, Oct., 26

Book: Habermas, Jürgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest…
Wed. Oct. 24: Student presentations continue

Week 9:
Wed., Oct., 31

Friday, Nov., 2
Article: Schaffer, Jonathan (2005) “Knowing the Answer”…
Article: Goldman, Alvin I. (1979) “What is Justified Belief?”…

Friday, Nov. 2: Student presentations Continue
Week 10:
Wed., Nov., 7

Friday, Nov., 9 Book: Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organizations Studies…

Presentation of Essay Proposals

Nov. 9 – Nov 30th presentation of essay proposals
Week 11:
Wed., Nov., 14

Friday, Nov., 16

Week 12:
Wed., Nov., 21

Friday, Nov., 23

Week 13:
Wed., Nov., 28

Friday, Nov., 30

Week 14:
Wed., Dec., 5 (last day of Class)

Friday, Dec., 7
Exam period begins Final Essay is due

Resources for you

Mentoring Centre – http://www.sciencessociales.uottawa.ca/mentor/fra/
The goal of the Mentoring Centre is to help students with their academic and social well being during their time at the University of Ottawa. Regardless of where a student stands academically, or how far along they are in completing their degree, the mentoring centre is there to help students continue on their path to success.

A student may choose to visit the mentoring centre for very different reasons. Younger students may wish to talk to their older peers to gain insight into programs and services offered by the University, while older student may simply want to brush up on study and time management skills or learn about programs and services for students nearing the end of their degree.

In all, the Mentoring Centre offers a place for students to talk about concerns and problems that they might have in any facet of their lives. While students are able to voice their concerns and problems without fear of judgment, mentors can garner further insight in issues unique to students and find a more practical solution to better improve the services that the Faculty of Social Sciences offers, as well as the services offered by the University of Ottawa.

Academic Writing Help Centre – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/writing/
At the AWHC you will learn how to identify, correct and ultimately avoid errors in your writing and become an autonomous writer. In working with our Writing Advisors, you will be able to acquire the abilities, strategies and writing tools that will enable you to:
• Master the written language of your choice
• Expand your critical thinking abilities
• Develop your argumentation skills
• Learn what the expectations are for academic writing

Career Services – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/careers/
Career Services offers various services and a career development program to enable you to recognize and enhance the employability skills you need in today’s world of work.

Counseling Service – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/personal/
There are many reasons to take advantage of the Counseling Service. We offer:
• Personal counseling
• Career counseling
• Study skills counseling

Access Service – http://www.sass.uottawa.ca/acces/
The Access Service contributes to the creation of an inclusive environment by developing strategies and implementing measures that aim to reduce the barriers to learning for students who have learning disabilities, health, psychiatric or physical conditions.

Student Resources Centers – http://www.communitylife.uottawa.ca/en/resources.php
The Student Resources Centers aim to fulfill all sorts of students needs.

 

Be Aware of Academic Fraud!

Academic fraud is an act committed by a student and it can negatively effect your school evaluation (with respect to assignments, tests, exams, etc.). It is not tolerated by the University. Anyone found guilty of fraud will be liable to severe penalties.

Here are some examples of Academic Fraud:
• Plagiarize or cheat in any way;
• Present falsified research data;
• Submission of an assignment that, in part or in entirety, you are not the author of;
• Presentation of, without written permission of the professor(s) concerned, the same work from another course;

Over the years, the perfection of the Internet has strongly facilitated the discovery of cases of plagiarism. The tools that are at the disposal of your professors permit, with the help of only a few words, to retrace the origin of a text on the Web.

For more information on fraud and how to avoid it, you can refer to the Faculty web page, which offers tips to help you with your studies and the writing process for university level projects at the following address: http://www.socialsciences.uottawa.ca/eng/ugrad_tips.asp. You can also refer to the Faculty web page for information on plagiarism and university assignments:
http://www.socialsciences.uottawa.ca/eng/ethics.asp.

The person who committed or attempts to commit academic fraud or who was an accomplice will be punished. Here are some examples of sanctions that could be imposed:
• The assignment or course in question will receive a grade of “F”;
• An additional requirement will be added to the program of study (3 to 30 credits);
• Suspension or expulsion from the Faculty.

Over the past session, the majority of people found guilty of fraud received an “F” in their course and will need to obtain three to twelve extra credits in their program of study.

You may refer to the following address to find the regulations:
http://www.uottawa.ca/academic/info/newsletter/fraud_e.html

1
Course Rationale
Course Name: Knowledge Society and Social Organizations
Course Code, Number and Section: SOC 4303 A
Fall 2012

Prof. Karim .A.H.A. Hasan
http://karimhasan.com/about/
Currently, the twenty first century, we live a period which is known in the discipline of sociology “Modern Society”. Modern Society may be characterized and defined as “knowledge society”, which has “complex organizational structure”. It does relay on rationality of knowledge methods in social sciences, human sciences, and natural sciences, knowledge methods of “cost-benefit” analysis, “laissez-fair” theories and methods in economic management. The decline in the elementary forms of management and governance of life certainly has been noted with the emergence and formalization of scientific knowledge methods of the enlightenment period, the industrial revolution, and capitalist system of production.

Knowledge is accurate result of operationalization of tested outcome of variables, concepts, which may require a number of methods and tests of rational/logical validity and justifications generally defined: epistemic validation. Epistemic validations do rely on methods of evidence, facts. Validations require, formulated programmatic project provisions, for example, solution of problems, curing an illness, building a school, writing a legislation, formulating a new constitution to free a nation/to lead a nation to total freedom from bondage…etc. are processes and projects of knowledge constructions.

We have two major categories of knowledge which are produced and constructed with different methods of knowledge production. The first category is scholarly, academic, formal knowledge which requires specific methods, formal organizations, educational institutions, and the government all together form the “formal knowledge system”. The second is non-formal knowledge, which is categorized “practical knowledge”. Practical knowledge is obtained through trial and error method of

knowledge production. Formal methods and processes of knowledge production are rigorous, rule-based, may need laboratory testing, scholastic methods for researching the subject-matter, they are less likely to go wrong, more accurate, in particular the natural sciences, medicine, engineering…etc. Similarly, in the discipline of sociology and other social sciences formal processes of knowledge production follow the similar process and procedure of rationalization, hypothesis formulations and testing.

The non-formal knowledge is produced in the realm of everyday-life experiences and practices. It draws justification and validation methods “practical reason”, which mobilized trial-error method to produce a category of knowledge that we define “practical knowledge”, because it gets obtained in practice without real, actual prior intended formulation and agenda in certain instances. Thus, practical knowledge production requires less formal methods, they emerge out of trial-error method application of common sense practices of problem solving projects.

Although our society and its individual members, modern society in the twenty first century in the formal and non-formal spheres of life do rely on “knowledge” of the living and non-living to organize itself, to rationalize its structure, to make choices , to decide and categorize its goals, to decide and define “good”, “bad”…etc. This main characteristic of modern society that it is a “knowledge society”, in the twenty first century, religion and culture are two main fields of belief and practice which operate in the realm of “practical knowledge, practical reason”.

At best, the knowledge and rationality embedded in the two systems of knowledge production are not based on belief, of which trial-error and common sense methods are not actually accepted as knowledge production procedures until such point in time that the result is clearly received. The likelihoods of failure in trial-error methods and common sense methods are eight out of ten higher than the tested proved method formal methods of knowledge production. “Culture and belief” do not operate on principles of scientific knowledge. The rationality, which is a decisive measure of validity about whether a practice, an activity is accepted on the basis of principles of valid, verifiable scientific knowledge are not a preference influenced by prejudices, cultural up-brining, beliefs, religion, and the conditionings associated with them.

The formal sphere of government and economic activities do mainly rely on cost-benefit analysis, calculative-thinking, which are practices grounded in scientific formulations in economic methods of probabilities for deciding economic vales, prices, profits and wages in the management and
governance of the health, wealth and safety of the society. The formal sphere of government with the associated economic activities do require high level of professionalism, bureaucracy and administrative management, which are dependent on the rational episteme of management and governance of modern societies and their formal – complex associated organizations.

The laws which govern modern societies, societies like ours, are enforced by the government, its ministries, the quasi-government organizations to which the government has delegated power to act on behalf of the government, the civil society organizations which are governed by those laws explicitly and implicitly rely on justification and validations that decision-making method processes and universal principles, which extend justice to everyone regardless of age, sex, age, colour, race, national origin…etc, are based on scientific knowledge.

Constitutional legal guarantees of universal justice are guarantees of equal rights, equal opportunities…etc, for all of citizens; they are the product of scientific research and the accumulation of knowledge of practices of justice, which evades non-rational, invalid, prejudicial discrimination. Any errors and misjudgments in law are reviewable and appealable; the legislations which do not pass the test of constitutionality are sent back to parliament for amendments and corrections.

Thus, the laws which govern our society are rational, knowledge-based, our laws are not arbitrary. Practices of democracy, “peace, order and good governance” and “responsible government” are categories of practices which have been formulated and institutionalized as the result of precise and accurate knowledge of governance over centuries of accumulation of knowledge in management and government.
Modern society, which emerged at the end of seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries scientific revolution, discoveries and innovations in technology, engineering have led to innovations in communication technology, i.e., the telephone, internet, satellite communication technology, space exploration, embryo research, genetic modification of plants, vegetables, fruits and of humans specie.

Continuous and progressive research in social, political and economic sciences have produced new knowledge about governance and management of the society, that criticised the status-quo during the enlightenment period, which continues to this date, an age of criticism, rethinking, review, re-evaluation of social, political, economic and religious life. The beginning of individuality, rights and freedoms of individual responsibilities are characteristics of modern societies. The “indivisible sovereign authority”, the model upon which the kings, queens, emperors and other earthly sovereign powers drew inspiration to establish “Omniscient and Omnipotent and Omnipresent” authority of their subjects, similar to the authority of “God” on the earth were divided at the dawn of modernity among the religious institutions, the nobility, the kings courts…etc, thereafter among institutions of government, civil society…etc.

French revolution in later part of eighteenth century brought the most important change and innovation to nature of power and governance. It took to pieces the unanimity of absolute sovereignty, the revolution shattered absolute sovereignty, divided it and returned the power to people, institutionalized a new form of sovereignty, which is a celebrated respectable practice of democracy, the revolution made “people the sovereign”, known in political science “popular sovereignty”. The French revolution showed a progressive-knowledge-based change to the rest of Europe, which had not been seen in Europe in centuries. The revolution did vanquish the symbols of indivisible absolute sovereignty and freed the people from the shackles of ignorance; it was a progressive-change which almost entire Europe did follow.

What was, were the reasons which made those changes and the emergence of institutionalization of knowledge-based society possible? What was, were the causes which necessitated those new developments which led to the emergence of knowledge based society and its associated organizations, and how did it happen? The successful institutionalization and formalization of the new rational system which provided the base-knowledge for formation of knowledge society, modern society, were mainly due to the fallacies, inefficiencies of the pre-modern system of governance and management which relied on arbitrary, non-rational system of governance of the health, wealth, freedoms of the society.

Thus, health, wealth, justice, freedom, safety …etc, of the society in general necessitated new techniques and methods of knowledge production, a number of these new techniques and methods were discovered through programmatic projects, rational-calculative projects, the other category were discovered by accident and through ordinary trial-error activities of everyday life.
The opponents of reason, justice, modernity and knowledge-based society have been challenging the management and governance of the society, they are distorting the principles and applications of scientific knowledge, which are valid and justifiable universally, they are timeless and everlasting necessary for our safety, security, health, wealth…etc.

We, the defenders/protectors of knowledge, justice, freedom, reason may continue to find ourselves in this unreasonable, unjustifiable war with the “other side”, with opponents of enlightenment project who reject science, justice, freedom based on their own cultural prejudices and their “belief”, because the “other side” does not come to terms and does not consent to the principles of accurate knowledge justifiable by scientific methods which support freedom, justice, rights equally regardless of race, gender, ethnicity, religion…etc. Henceforth, any form of consensus may only be mediated /negotiated by “law” or “alliance of temporary interests”.

Thus, we must not expect an end to the quarrel between knowledge and belief. People may find themselves, either take a clear side, be moderate observant critically …etc. or they may find themselves unable to a take clear position which is difficult to hold and to maintain. Despite all those tensions, knowledge and its associated practices of justice, freedom are living being which constantly have progressed for thousands of years and will continue in similar direction as have been in the past to the present.

A brief Synopsis of the Main Readings
This synopsis has been organized chronologically starting with earliest sociologists and social scientists.

Mike, Gane (2006) Auguste Comte, Routledge, New York.
Reading Auguste Comte (1798-1857) who is one of the main early founders of sociology is central to the understanding of discipline of sociology. A good, through education in society must begin with the reading of Auguste Comte. Comte is recognized as the founder of “positive sociology – positive polity”, which is “secular humanism”, “religion of humanism”, concepts and practices that have contributed to the sub-discipline of “sociology of science” and recognition of sociology as “social science”.

Comte is a forgotten sociologist. His works range in dozens of very, very important large volumes of books, which have provide the discipline of sociology certain findings and teachings that have been central for the understanding the development of human societies with newly innovative research methods he questioned the traditional non-scientific, cultural prejudicial belief fallacies that governed formal and non-formal system of thoughts and practices. Although Comte’s own personal life does not reflect his works, we do really have to read his works in the context of his time period, the context of the social, political and economic conditions which governed France during his time period.

Humanism, positivism, scientific methods of inquiry in social sciences are approach and methods, which Comte contributed to the discipline of sociology and social sciences are very relevant to present-day discipline of sociology subject matters in university teaching and in real life sphere. They are the sources we have to rely on to read and to limit diversions from knowledge to arbitrary non-scientific methods of governance and management of the society. Comte’s works, scientific methods of inquiry, his contribution to the study of law are excellent start to begin advanced studies and understanding of the discipline of sociology and social sciences.

Marx, Karl, et. al., (1935) Value, Price, and Profit, International Publishers, New York.
Although Karl Marx (1818-1883) has been, is, considered one of the major sociologists – political economists in academic – scholarly communities, his ideological belief and associations with “political socialism” and “political communism”, and his call on the working class to destroy capitalist system of production, have led to categorization of his work as non-objective, ideological and politically oriented. As the result, scholars of who consider their own work within the category of objectivity, who claim that knowledge must be scientific-objective, value laden, non-ideological have been weary and skeptical of admitting Karl Marx’s work openly in academic – scholarly communities of associations.

His criticisms and evaluations of capitalist method – system of production that capitalist system of production ends, and that the system falls within itself because of certain internal deficiencies and quarrel within it, thereafter leads to new form of social, political and economic life “socialism” and then “communism”, which according to Marx will occur in the form of “working class revolution” to over turn capitalist system of production has been proven inaccurate. Current, discreet and more accurate analysis and studies reveal that Marx’s certain studies capital system of production and his critique of political economy are highly scientific, which have contributed to knowledge of economic production, but his political ideology is inaccurate and highly unlikely to receive further consideration.

However, his work which focuses on “production, value, price, profit and wage” presents basic – fundamental evaluation of capitalist system of production are highly accurate, and his criticisms are supplementary to the understandings of certain fallacies, injustices inherent within capitalist system of production, henceforth, reading and understanding Karl Marx’s work, the sociologist – political economist, not Karl Marx the “socialist – communist” is every important and necessary for all students of sociology and the sub-field of political economy with the discipline of sociology.

Fair, justifiable, viable balance of values, price, profit, wages are central to the foundation and functioning system of economic production. Thus, understanding criticisms which Marx presented may lead to further review of capitalist system of production and class based society, in which the classes live at certain degree of conflict over the means and ends of economic production. Marx’s contribution to sociology is the organization of the society into classes in accordance with their economic power and ownership of the means of production is accurate reading of political economy.

Durkheim, Emile (1984) The division of Labor in Society, Free Press, New York.
Distinguishing and organizing the differences and similarities in the division of labor force are governed differently in pre-modern and modern societies. In pre-modern societies the form of organization – solidarity is “mechanical”, which is a simple form of social organization and division of labor.

According to Durkheim (1858-1917), “organic solidarity” is the form of social organization and division of labor in modern societies, in which mode or economic production is capitalist. Durkheim’s Division of Labor is one of the most important sociological sources, which shows the ways in which progress / development from primitive – elementary forms of mechanical solidarity of social organization that consists of arbitrary, non-knowledge based, non-scientific methods of governance of social, political and economic life did no-longer hold the capacity, and lost the validity as the system of organization and management.

Mechanical form of solidarity organizes communities into simple communal life, their leaders do posses and they are accepted as charismatic leaders who are followed as sacred, spiritual guides, “gurus” who serve their communities without any reward. They are accepted as if they were appointed to the task by the high supreme-being. Communal life in mechanical solidarity is similar to “cyborg” communities which we see in science fiction movies, life is commanded / managed at the centre; the community follows the same order without questionings and doubts.

In “mechanical solidarity” system sovereigns and charismatic leaders possess privacy; the nobility, religious institutions, the sovereign’s associates enjoy privacy when the sovereign, the charismatic leader delegate – grant a degree of private life. Consequently, cause and effect has led to formation of a new form of social organization proper for modern societies, which is a knowledge-based society.

“Organic solidarity” is system of organization which relies on science, knowledge, evidence, justification, validation and the rationale of complex system of associations and consociation of organizations in which individuals and groups are members, who are working for the same or similar objectives. Individualism does find a welcoming space and place within mechanical form of social solidarity. The sources of authority in modern society, which is organized in the form of “organic solidarity”, although relevant to modern norms, are important; the “Law” is a formal system, rules and regulations which supplement the law apply to the public, and to private spheres of life at certain instances.

The division between public and private receives far more technical interpretation. Private domain-sphere which was only the luxury and domain of the kings, queens and the sovereigns, extended to ordinary citizens alike. In organic solidarity in modern societies, system of rights, responsibilities and freedoms do allow group interest formations which are legally / formally recognized. They may not be in agreement with their concurrent government and authority; however, “unity in diversity” may be the best term to describe the constituent collision of interests, remains within the framework of broader system and a wider communal good than the presumed communal good which mainly the sovereign, the charismatic leader and their associates defined, enjoyed and were the beneficiaries.

Almost a century and half has passed since the passing of Emile Durkheim, the French sociologist, his work remains highly relevant to our present day – modern society, his work remains central to the discipline of sociology and social sciences.

Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essay in Sociology, Oxford University Press, New York.
Max Weber (1958-1917) German sociologist, have contributed to sociology is mainly in the fields of “economy and society”. His life begun at the dawn of modern –industrial revolution in Europe, a period in which complex social, political and economic activities were necessitating new formation of social, political and economic organization for the management and the governance of the society. Cause and effect explanation would be a highly accurate approach by which change from elementary form of organization to modern knowledge-based from of organization may be explained – as Weber has presented in his work.

Weber’s concerns and focus of studies among others: bureaucracy and charisma, forms of administration, science and politics, power, class, status, party-politics, social structures, religion in the East and West. Unlike the scholars and scientists who argued and defended that the “enlightenment project” was the initial intellectual programmatic beginning of change toward modernity, rationality, justice, individual freedom, freedom from traditional authority of religion, in particular the Church and Papacy, over ordinary life in the “earthly city”.

Weber related the rise of the modern freedom from “religion” and the formation of modern rational society to “Puritan Anglo-American Tradition”i which he finds in the “spiritual revolution: the Protestant Reformation of the Sixteenth Century”ii.

Although Weber’s claim and research that “protestant reformation” with “Puritan Anglo-American Tradition” have lead the development of Western societies to modern social, political and economic system-structure to which capital mode of production is the economic-base, has a degree of accuracy, Weber’s reliance on the reformation movement as the central departing point from the traditions of the middle ages and previous system of government, which he has claimed to have been the leading intellectual movement that founded and formed modern societies is inaccurate and simplistic.

More accurate explanation is that an aggregate of social, political, economic movements, new scientific discoveries, industrial revolution, French Revolution rose at the centre of Catholicism, descendents of Charlemagne of France brought new form of governance, ended absolutism, replaced it with republican-democratic rule, rule of the people, for the people, by the people, a type revolution which spread all over Europe in the decades and centuries thereafter; Renaissance – rebirth of cultural practices in South East Europe in particular Italian Renaissance, which are selected collection of practices in social, political intellectual movements from perhaps early Greek philosophers and aristocracy, the “philosophers kings”…etc., and their Middle Eastern roots are all aggregates of knowledge practices which have contributed to the formation of modern rational, knowledge-based societies.

French Revolution is element of the Enlightenment project, which has inspired and aided the United States of America’s formation to freedom. Thus, although Weber remains an important classical sociologist, whose work is yet relevant, he shows us many details of the development of Western societies to modern, knowledge based societies, his account, claiming all the credit to the protestant reformation is inaccurate.

Weber’s relevancy to this course may be summarized in three main points. First, Weber is one of the founder/elaborators of discipline of formal sociology of modern societies, knowledge-based society. Second, Weber is one of the first sociologists who wrote on modern social, political and economic organizations; he provided extensive analysis most components of modern societies, which he successfully showed that they are not based on arbitrary methods of governance, rather they function on principles re rationality, bureaucratic administration…etc.

Third, Weber’s ‘sociology of religion’ provides an excellent comparative analysis of the principle claims religions of West, Middle Easter and Eastern religions, the centrality of reason and rationality, their application to worldly life, pragmatism, are the main analytic and evaluation criterion. Weber uses rationality and knowledge in similar way, if the two were the identical. Although “knowledge” and “reason” are interrelated and connected, they are not the equivalent.

Habermas, Jϋrgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest, Beacon Press, Boston.

Knowledge and Human Interest shows the ways in which human interest influences production of knowledge and justification for selection of certain choice-makings, which are driven-caused by human interest, certain interests are justified and allowed, certain specified interested are regulated or prohibited. The nature of knowledge is such that it is influenced by interest, where there is space for manipulation of knowledge which operates the system; there are limited acceptable choices within the system among the available choices.

The selection method of choice making must be justified on principles of justice and reason, which to contribute to the formation of the system that has been built – structured on the type of knowledge equipped with universal justice and reason. Habermas is the defender of Enlightenment project, the centrality of reason, universal justice…etc. The epistemological validation which attempts to free knowledge from interest does fail, if interest is not regulated and governed by the universal principle of knowledge, mainly because interest is the motive and the drive, which may divert knowledge formation to unjustified, invalid directions that may lead to epistemic-failure.

Although, “human interest” is the central driving force, the motif which pushes forward the process of knowledge formation of material objects, construction of formal social, political and
economic system and practical knowledge of everyday life; interest cannot be an inherently acceptable cause of knowledge that leads to justified, valid, free-good life, which is governed by just-law.
Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organization Studies in the Post-Modern World, Sage, London.

Although it is not the purpose of this course to focus on modernity and post-modernity debates, debates which intent to define, to characterize whether we live in the modern or the postmodern period, because this course’s main focus is the study of knowledge society and its relevant models/methods of organization and the development from pre-modern to modern knowledge-based system, it is useful to include a source which brings the development of “organizations” to attention.

If clearly we agree either that we live in postmodern social, political and economic system, or if we agree about its recent emergence, or if we agree that modern social, political and economic system has not passed and still we live in the modern period, in either instance of these “if-clauses”, the answer to the main question which this course focuses on would have a different impact for “the universality of knowledge”, “standardization of knowledge”, whether we live in knowledge-based society, will cause further differentiations, distinctions, and different consequences for the management and governance of the social, political and economic system.

Postmodern approach to “knowledge and organization” is different than modern approach to “knowledge and organization”. Standard and measurements which knowledge is assessed and defined in postmodern society may differ from the modern definitions and standards of knowledge.

References
Durkheim, Emile (1984) The division of Labor in Society, Free Press, New York.
Habermas, Jurgen (1972) Knowledge and Human Interest, Beacon Press, Boston.
Mike, Gane (2006) Auguste Comte, Routledge, New York.
Max, Karl, et. al., (1935) Value, Price, and Profit, International Publishers, New York.
Stewart, Clegg (1990) Modern Organizations: Organization Studies in the Post-Modern World, Sage, London.
Weber, Max (1970) From Max Weber: Essay in Sociology, Oxford University Press, New York.
Weber, Max (2002) The Protestant Ethics and the “Spirit” of Capitalism and other Writings, Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, England.
i Weber, Max () Protestant Ethics and Spirit of Capitalism… P., x
ii Ibid, at P., ix